Featured Mr.Newz ·

Now With 50% More Liberty: Indiana’s ACLU Split Produces a Second Nonprofit

Bob Taylor Contributor

The American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana has shed most of its legal staff. Those lawyers have incorporated a new group, the Civil Liberties Center of Indiana. Stevie Pactor is listed as executive director. Ken Falk, Gavin Rose, Josh Bleisch, and others are expected to join in January. The split followed the board’s selection of Nikkita Oliver as the next executive director and subsequent internal disputes over case selection and direction.

Indiana has seen this organization, and groups like it, litigate against small towns and counties when local decisions conflict with preferred national positions. In Martin County, the ACLU of Indiana sued the City of Loogootee after the council altered special-event rules following an election and declined to approve a Pride festival on the public square. Court orders followed. Similar actions have targeted other local governments over nativity displays, speech policies, and related matters. The pattern is consistent: outside litigators arrive with resources and counsel that small communities do not possess, and the outcome is frequently a settlement or injunction that overrides the local body’s stated preference.

The new nonprofit is staffed by the same attorneys who built that docket. Falk has directed the affiliate’s legal work for decades. The group’s articles of incorporation and public statements offer no indication that the case priorities will change. They do not announce a narrower focus on speech, religion, or association rights that might conflict with current progressive priorities. They do not describe a different standard for intervening in municipal affairs. The public record shows continuity of personnel and, so far, continuity of approach.

Oliver’s selection produced accusations, later denied, that the affiliate would apply a “harm reduction lens” and decline cases involving clients whose positions she rejected. Whether those accounts are accurate is secondary. The result is two organizations rather than one. One retains the ACLU name and the national network. The other retains the experienced litigators. Both will solicit donations and both will file suits. Communities that previously dealt with a single plaintiff will now have the option of two.

Small-town councils and school boards already operate with limited legal budgets. When a national or statewide nonprofit files suit, the practical choice is often to settle or absorb the cost of defense. The formation of a second entity does not reduce that pressure. It multiplies the potential plaintiffs while preserving the same institutional capacity that has been used against local governments in Martin County and elsewhere. Whether the new center produces different results, or simply additional filings under a different letterhead, will be measurable by the cases it chooses to bring. Until then, the difference is organizational.

Share

Thoughts · 0

No thoughts yet — be the first.